crumbsroom wrote:
And of course they are very different beasts, but that's what is interesting about contrasting their approaches. Both were early examples (maybe the two first?) of the improvisitory school of comedy figuring out how to make television. And in completely simplistic terms, SNL went with the edge, and SCTV went with the heart. Both are also full of successes and failures. Both are also completely valid as anyone's preference.
I think that Second City is at the heart of both of them. Maybe SNL's edge came more from its National Lampoon side (although even the Lampoon would employ Second City talent - Murray, Radner, Belushi, Raimis, and even Flaherty - for their radio shows and records). And, no, I don't really recognize much distinction between the Chicago and Toronto schools.
The crucial difference between SNL and SCTV is in the latter's choice not to use a live audience (and thankfully they dropped the canned laughs after the first couple of years). This goes directly to how they translated their humor from the theatrical stage. There's simply an energy in the performances that comes from a responsive audience, regardless of whether it's broadcast live or cut together later. The argument can be made that the lack of an audience allowed SCTV to provide a more meta satire of television as a medium. But combined with SCTV's more dry delivery, this was maybe the one element that I had to adapt to. But even still, when I remember actually watching SCTV on network television, these were the years when the only big attraction to SNL was Eddie Murphy, and the original cast were better known from their films at that point. And even there, there was a lot of overlap - Candy and Levy in Vacation, Flaherty in Stripes, Moranis in Ghostbusters.
In addition to being more "theatrical", I would also give those first early years of SNL the edge of having a deeper variety of comedy styles, more political and taboo than SCTV, aided by guests like Andy Kaufman, Albert Brooks, Carlin and Pryor, Mr. Bill, Mr. Mike, the Muppets. This preference only counts for these early seasons, because by the time the show found its footing in the mid-late 80s, it had a more established formula. But those early years, there's still an anarchic sense of not really knowing what to expect that stands up after watching those shows dozens of times. And I've also watched the SCTV shows dozens of times as well.