
It's unfair to judge the film based on its template of serial killer crime procedural tropes, because on that level the film doesn't stray too far from those conventions. Rather the primary draw is in the film's cultural and political context, which narratively resonates far deeper than had it been limited to simply supporting the thriller genre. (A similar criticism has been lobbed at Under the Shadow for the horror genre.) Such external significance is inescapable, especially given the death of Mahsa Amini mere months after its Cannes premiere and the widespread protests it provoked, itself a culmination of "White Wednesday" protests and the severity of the Iranian government's response to them, and it adds tremendously to the palpable provocation that the film itself represents. Added to this significance, of feminine subjugation and sexual austerity, is the powerful lead performance of actress Zar Amir Ebrahimi (who in real life has lived in exile in France for a decade due to a sex tape scandal), and the film's own troubled exile production in Turkey and Jordan which never entirely escaped the threat of Iranian pressure. Added to this, the real-life implications of popular support and government complicity in the 2000-01 factually based crimes. I had to fill in my own historical context by learning more about the more specific significances of the city of Mashhad and the legacy of Imam Reza after the fact (not entirely necessary for the film, but fascinating nonetheless). And for Ebrahimi's efforts, a Best Actress winner at Cannes, the very real-life death threats and pledges of persecution that followed the film's release. Along with No Bears (which saw its writer-director Jafar Panahi incarcerated), the film, far more than a sexually-tinged murder thriller, is a testament against an oppresion so insidiously ingrained it's become practically invisible. And, unfortunately, there's still some strange presumptions, such as why the clear lead performance of Ebrahimi gets second billing behind Mehdi Bajestani's serial killer. Bajestani is fine in the role, but still, it has to sting a little.
8/10